Please note: This list does NOT include those honored for excellence in the classroom sponsored by the governing body for that sport, such as the United Soccer Coaches (USC) or the National Field Hockey Coaches Association (NFHCA), for example. The following are those named Academic All-American from The University of Scranton by formerly the College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) and now known as College Sports Communicators (CSC).
Baseball (6)
- Connor Harding - 2019 (1st team), 2020 (2nd team), 2021 (1st team), 2022 (1st team)
- David Giglio – 2011 (2nd team)
- Chris Stallone – 2009 (3rd team), 2010 (1st team), 2011 (1st team)
- Justin Champagne – 2008 (3rd team), 2010 (1st team)
- Scott Sannito - 1990 (1st team)
- Greg Moro - 1986 (honorable mention)
Field Hockey (1)
- Allie Benadon - 2022 (3rd team)
Men's Golf (1)
- Will Carey III – 1988 (2nd team)
Men's Basketball (5)
- Zach Ashworth – 2010 (2nd team), 2011 (1st team)
- Matt Cusano - 1993 (1st team)
- J.P. Andrejko - 1987 (3rd team), 1988 (3rd team)
- Dan Polacheck - 1985
- Michael Banas - 1982 (3rd team), 1983 (1st team), 1984 (1st team)
Men's Cross-Country (2)
- John Mercuri – 2005 (2nd team), 2006 (1st team), 2007 (1st team)
- Joe Fent - 2000 (3rd team), 2001 (2nd team)
Men's Soccer (3)
- Logan Campbell - 2024 (2nd team)
- Matt Busch - 2016 (2nd team)
- Bill McGuiness - 2012 (1st team), 2013 (1st team)
Men's Swimming (1)
- David Hovey - 2012 (3rd team)
Men's Tennis (3)
- Tarquin McGurrin - 2021 (3rd team)
- Tim McGurrin - 2012 (3rd team), 2013 (2nd team)
- Clay Yeager - 1994 (3rd team), 1995 (2nd team), 1996 (1st team)
Softball (5)
- Megan Zinn - 2019 (1st team), 2020 (1st team), 2021 (2nd team)
- Shannon Stricker - 2017 (3rd team)
- Kelly Zaccheo - 2012 (3rd team)
- Cheryl Zekas - 1990 (3rd team)
- Kelly Guiton - 1987 (2nd team)
Women's Basketball (6)
- Kaci Kranson - 2025 (3rd team)
- Meredith Mesaris - 2015 (2nd team)
- Jennifer Nish - 1995 (3rd team), 1996 (2nd team), 1997 (3rd team)
- Shelley Ritz-Buntz - 1986 (2nd team), 1987 (3rd team)
- Fran Harkins - 1983 (honorable mention)
- Deb Krzywiec - 1981 (2nd team)
Women's Cross-Country (1)
- Theresa Meade - 1984 (2nd team), 1986 (1st team)
Women's Golf (1)
- Maddy Buhler - 2023 (2nd team)
Women's Lacrosse (1)
- Bridget Lee – 2003 (1st team)
Women's Soccer (6)
- Nicole Olson - 2022, 2024 (1st team)
- Niamh Healy - 2023, 2024 (2nd team)
- Rebecca Russo - 2019 (3rd team)
- Erin Casey - 2016 (2nd team)
- Emily Farrell - 2012 (3rd team)
- Nicole Bayman - 2001 (1st team)
Women's Swimming (2)
- Lauren Byrne - 2021 (2nd team), 2022 (2nd team)
- Sarah Gazdalski - 2000 (3rd team), 2001 (1st team)
Women's Tennis (1)
- Tracy Graybill - 1987 (2nd team)
Wrestling (3)
- Jacob Burgette - 2024, 2025
- Jeremiah Oakes - 2024
- Michael Grandchamp - 1999 (3rd team)
