Female O'Hara Award - Presented annually to the outstanding female student-athletes in the senior class
- 2025 - Grace Lane, Nicole Olson
- 2024 - Niamh Healy, Katie Redding
- 2023 - Bridget Monaghan
- 2022 - Hope Drewes, Jennifer Sweeney
- 2021 - Megan Zinn
- 2020 - Becca Russo
- 2019 - Bridgette Mann
- 2018 - Meredith Campbell
- 2017 - Sarah Payonk
- 2016 - Emily Walsh
- 2015 - Julia Crilly, Meredith Mesaris
- 2014 - Samantha Russo
- 2013 - Gretchen Kempf
- 2012 - Carrie Gillespie
- 2011 - Chelsea Paskman
- 2010 - Lauren Wieland
- 2009 - Erin O’Connor
- 2008 - Mary Beth Vogel
- 2007 - Taryn Mellody
- 2006 - Kelly Herlihy
- 2005 - Sara Suchoski
- 2004 - Kate Pierangeli
- 2003 - Liz Baumbach
- 2002 - Meghan Quinlan
- 2001 - Amy Connolly, Sarah Gazdalski
- 2000 - Kelly Halpin
- 1999 - Kate Dougherty, Jennifer Knight
- 1998 - AnnaMaria Rigolio, Stephanie Plaza
- 1997 - Jen Nish
- 1996 - Dawn Ennis, Erin Kenney
- 1995 - Margot Royer
- 1994 - Jackie Dougherty
- 1993 - Lynn Kempski
- 1992 - Lynn Flannery, Laura Pikulski
- 1991 - Holly Spiech
- 1990 - Traci Zarbatany
- 1989 - Judy Grimaldi, Karen Barlow
- 1988 - Sue Cately
- 1987 - Una Espenkotler
- 1986 - Denise Atkinson
- 1985 - Mary Leedy
- 1984 - Sue Moore
- 1983 - Fran Harkins, Mary Ann Tarentino
- 1982 - Sandy Cameli
- 1981 - Kathy Coleman
- 1980 - Alyce Ruane
- 1979 - Judy Moye
Male O'Hara Award - Presented annually to the outstanding male student-athletes in the senior class
- 2025 - Danny Harding
- 2024 - Tim Lanahan
- 2023 - Christopher Crapanzano
- 2022 - Jackson Danzig, Tyler Kirsten
- 2021 - Connor Harding
- 2020 - Keegan Connelly
- 2019 - Dan D’Agostini
- 2018 - Tommy Trotter
- 2017 - Eric Hintz, John Vitkus
- 2016 - Brendan Boken
- 2015 - Ross Danzig
- 2014 - Tommy Morgan
- 2013 - Bill McGuiness
- 2012 - Luke Hawk
- 2011 - Zach Ashworth
- 2010 - Chris Bligh
- 2009 - Ryan FitzPatrick, Tim Logan
- 2008 - Randy Arnold
- 2007 - Dan Stallone
- 2006 - Michael Cottone
- 2005 - Brian O’Donnell
- 2004 - Kyle Eaton
- 2003 - Darren Buseman
- 2002 - Michael Burns, Eric Kunzinger
- 2001 - Joe Fent
- 2000 - Henry Condron
- 1999 - Jason Fisher, Mike Grandchamp
- 1998 - Rick Adrid
- 1997 - Charles Nanick
- 1996 - Clay Yager
- 1995 - Pat Beacham
- 1994 - Joseph Schmidt
- 1993 - Jason Hoppy
- 1992 - Drew Morano
- 1991 - Douglas Edwards
- 1990 - Michael Kane
- 1989 - Tim Dimarco, Steve Daigle
- 1988 - J.P. Andrejko
- 1987 - Jeffrey Arestivo
- 1986 - Hugh O’Neill
- 1985 - Bill Bessoir
- 1984 - Mickey Banas
- 1983 - William McNeel
- 1982 - Cedric DeSilva
- 1981 - Tim Kelly
- 1980 - John Keating
- 1979 - Glen Brodwater
- 1978 - John Gill, Jim Rauer
- 1977 - John DeRichie
- 1976 - Jack Maher
- 1975 - Glen Wolsieffer
- 1974 - Jo-Jo Cantafio
- 1973 - Pete Hurley
- 1972 - Doug Kohler
- 1971 - Tom Farrell
- 1970 - Bob Steinberg
Female Carlesimo Award - Presented annually to a female senior student-athlete(s) for outstanding academic and athletic achievement
- 2025 - Samantha Hoffman, Nicole Olson
- 2024 - Maddy Buhler
- 2023 - Teresa Hegarty
- 2022 - Allie Benadon
- 2021 - Lauren Byrne
- 2020 - Becca Russo
- 2019 - Erica Licari
- 2018 - Morgan Rentzheimer
- 2017 - Sarah Payonk
- 2016 - Erin Casey
- 2015 - Stephanie Romano
- 2014 - Devon Cohen
- 2013 - Emily Farrell, Kathleen Smart
- 2012 - Kelly Zaccheo
- 2011 - Julia Kropf, Katie Slade
- 2010 - Stephanie Huth
- 2009 - Jacqueline Pisano
- 2008 - Brooke Hinkley
- 2007 - Taryn Mellody
- 2006 - Cassie Dyer, Theresa Szczepanski
- 2005 - Marta DeLong
- 2004 - Krista Hylinski
- 2003 - Bridget Lee
Male Carlesimo Award - Presented annually to a male senior student-athlete(s) for outstanding academic and athletic achievement
- 2025 - Christian Snee
- 2024 - Tim Lanahan
- 2023 - Brendan King
- 2022 - Shane McKeon
- 2021 - Connor Harding
- 2020 - Michael Diana
- 2019 - Dan D’Agostini
- 2018 - Keller McGurrin
- 2017 - Matthew Busch
- 2016 - Ryan Brown
- 2015 - Michael Ambrose
- 2014 - Ryan Saraceni
- 2013 - Tim McGurrin
- 2012 - David Hovey
- 2011 - Chris Stallone
- 2010 - Justin Champagne
- 2009 - Kyle Fox
- 2008 - Tom Bicknell
- 2007 - John Mercuri
- 2006 - Bill Burke, Casper Magacs
- 2005 - Nick DeBarbrie
- 2004 - John Barlow
- 2003 - Dan Loftus
Female Fitzpatrick Award - Presented annually to a female senior student-athlete(s) for outstanding leadership and community service
- 2025 - Julie Rogel
- 2024 - Nicole Kenny
- 2023 - Lauren McGuire
- 2022 - No Recipient
- 2021 - Annie Amentler
- 2020 - Claire McAllister
- 2018 - Katie Allen, Maeve Potter
- 2017 - Jessica Schmidt
- 2016 - Bridget Gallaher
- 2015 - Megan Azzalina, Nicole Mahaffey
- 2014 - Kerry Sullivan
- 2013 - Sarah Gibbons, Lindsay Ward
- 2012 - Christina Cognetti
- 2011 - Julia Kropf
- 2010 - Eileen Sodano
- 2009 - Katie Cordier, Kristina Goetz
- 2008 - Karolyn Holody, Mary Beth Vogel
- 2007 - Angela Croteau
- 2006 - Katie McKenna
- 2005 - Maria Hundersmarck
- 2004 - Katie Szczepanski
- 2003 - Maureen Bole
- 2002 - Christine Fontaine, Kristy Petty
- 2001 - Kelly Pippett
- 2000 - Patty Dougherty
Male Fitzpatrick Award - Presented annually to a male senior student-athlete(s) for outstanding leadership and community service
- 2025 - No Recipient
- 2024 - No Recipient
- 2023 - No Recipient
- 2022 - John Murphy
- 2021 - No Recipient
- 2020 - Riley Smith
- 2019 - Chris Whalen
- 2018 - Richard Endico
- 2017 - Jimmy Buckley
- 2016 - No recipient
- 2015 - Ryan Holmes, Michael Umerich
- 2014 - Michael Gaeta
- 2013 - James Bresnaham
- 2012 - David Hovey
- 2011 - Joseph Costello, Carl Caceres
- 2010 - Scott Melideo
- 2009 - Chris Psihoules
- 2008 - John Gennaoui
- 2007 - John Mercuri
- 2006 - Michael Clark, Nick Costanzo
- 2005 - Brendan Connors
- 2004 - No recipient
- 2003 - Bobby Davis
- 2002 - Mark Malczynski
- 2001 - Bryan Ruda
- 2000 - Brian Eberhardt
Willensky Award - Presented to a senior student-athlete who has overcome extreme hardship in their athletic career and/or personal life
- 2025 - No recipient
- 2024 - Jeremiah Oakes
- 2023 - George Jenkins
- 2022 - Kevin Johnson
- 2021 - Meaghan Dowdell, Matthew Pinto
- 2020 - Jasmin Russo
- 2018 - Tim McGovern
- 2017 - Matt Prendergast
- 2016 - No recipient
- 2015 - No recipient
- 2014 - Kaitlyn Greeley
- 2013 - Bobby Della Polla
- 2012 - Alicia Tamboia
- 2011 - Amie Leonard, Chelsea Paskman
- 2010 - Ralph Elliott, Scott Garbe
- 2009 - Gary Racich
- 2008 -Brooke Hinkley
- 2007 - Sean O’Connor
- 2006 - Heather Bradley
- 2005 - Jessica Ranson
- 2004 - Judy Flounders
- 2003 - Amy O’Rourke
- 2002 - Patricia Donaghy
- 2001 - Nicole Bayman
- 2000 - Patrick Owen
- 1999 - Kristine Reilly
- 1998 - Karin Sandstrom
- 1997 - Chris Arnone
- 1996 - Mary Strasser
- 1995 - Kevin Phelps
- 1994 - Don Pullano
- 1993 - Andrea Pizzato
Rev. Paul R. Beining, S.J. Award - Presented to individuals for special contributions to University of Scranton Athletics Year
- 2025 - Matt Davidson
- 2024 - Dr. Kimberly Pavlick
- 2023 - John Garzarella
- 2022 - Rev. Herbert B. Keller, S.J.
- 2021 - No Recipient
- 2020 - No Recipient
- 2019 - Dr. Willis Conover
- 2018 - Dean Corwin
- 2017 - Rev. Kevin P. Quinn, S.J
- 2016 - Canio Cianci
- 2015 - Kevin Southard
- 2014 - Dr. Harry Dammer
- 2013 - Ron Jordan
- 2012 - Dr. Patrick Leahy
- 2011 - Dr. Vincent Carilli
- 2010 - Rev. G. Donald Pantle, S.J.
- 2009 - Paul Cutrufello
- 2008 - Rita Snee
- 2007 - Jack “Doc” O’Malley
- 2006 - James “Jay” Schofield
- 2005 - John Ogden
- 2004 - John Kelly Mary Jones
Ocorr Student-Athlete Service Award - Presented to a senior student who has served “royally” the campus and/or the Greater Scranton Community during his/ her tenure
- 2025 - Vin Rinella
- 2024 - Erin Holler
- 2023 - Bryson Eldridge
- 2022 - Molly Dunfee
- 2021 - Amelia Sharp
- 2020 - Greg Spicka
