Baseball (2)

• Corey Zientek (2023)
• Thomas Sohns (1976)

Men's Basketball (11)

• Jackson Danzig (2023)
• Brendan Boken (2016)
• Zach Ashworth (2011)
• Matt Cusano (1993)
• Jason Hoppy (1993)
• J.P. Andrejko (1987, 1988)
• Bill Bessoir (1983, 1984, 1985)
• Irv Johnson (1977, 1978, 1980)
• Gene Mumford (1970, 1971)
• Bill Witaconis (1963)
• Ed Kazakavich (1959)

Women's Basketball (25)

• Kaci Kranson (2023, 2024, 2025)
• Bridget Monaghan (2021, 2022, 2023)
• Abby Anderson (2022)
• Makenzie Mason (2020)
• Bridgette Mann (2018, 2019)
• Sarah Payonk (2016, 2017)
• Meredith Mesaris (2014, 2015)
• Megan Kopecki (2009, 2010)
• Kathleen Daly (2008)
• Allison Matt (2006, 2007)
• Taryn Mellody (2005, 2006, 2007)
• Katie Dougherty (2004)
• Kate Pierangeli (2003, 2004)
• Kelly Halpin (1998, 1999, 2000)
• Jennifer Nish (1995, 1996, 1997)
• Jackie Dougherty (1994)
• Lynne Kempski (1993)
• Laura Pikulski (1992)
• Shelley Parks (1987)
• Una Espenkotter (1986)
• Deanna Kyle (1985)
• Melanie Bibak (1984)
• Fran Harkins (1981, 1983)
• Fran Gabriel (1982)
• Denise Capoocia (1980)

Men's Cross Country (1)

• Joseph Fent (1998, 2000)

Field Hockey (3)

• Katie Redding (2022, 2023, 2024)
• Allie Benadon (2021)
• Andrea Thompson (1997)

Golf (1)

• Will Carey (1987)

Men's Lacrosse (9)

• Zachariah Palinkas (2025)
• Matthew McAree (2024)
• Colin Pierce (2024)
• Christopher Crapanzano (2022, 2023)
• Collin Purdy (2021)
• Michael Elefonte (2019)
• Adam Drury (2017)
• Ryan Millard (2015)
• Tim Cleary (2012, 2013)

Women's Lacrosse (4)

• Grace Lane (2024, 2025)
• Emily Schum (2021, 2022)
• Becca Russo (2019)
• Liz Baumbach (2003)

Men's Soccer (11)

• Bill McGuiness (2012, 2013)
• Joseph Schmidt (1993)
• Doug Edwards (1990)
• Mike Kane (1988)
• Michael Capasso (1987)
• Magnus Ojert (1987)
• Jeffrey Arestivo (1986)
• Hugh O'Neill (1985)
• Daniel Diceanu (1984)
• William McNeel (1982)
• Cedric deSilva (1980, 1981)

Women's Soccer (12)

• Niamh Healy (2023, 2024, 2025)
• ???????Hope Drewes (2021)
• Teresa Hegarty (2021)
• Rebecca Russo (2018)
• Chelsea Paskman (2009, 2010)
• Sara Suchoski (2001, 2003)
• Nicole Bayman (2000)
• Nicole Amato (1999)
• Renee Zizza (1992)
• Holly Spiech (1988, 1989, 1990)
• Monica Davidson (1989)
• Sue Cately (1987)

Softball (2)

• Megan Zinn (2019)
• Jennifer Sweeney (2018)

Women's Cross Country (1)

• Jessica Hoffmann (2022)

Women's Swimming (3)

• Lauren Byrne (2020)
• Sarah Gazdalski (1999)
• Marilyn Bogusch (1989)

Women's Track & Field (1)

• Caroline Banas (2018)

Women's Volleyball (5)

• Erin Keaveney (2023, 2024)
• Deanna Whelpley (2023)
• Eryn Boken (2021)
• Kristin Kirwan (2017)
• ???????Julia Crilly (2014)

Wrestling (3)

• Keegan Connelly (2020)
• Darren Buseman (2003)
• Michael Grandchamp (1999)